Saturday, 15 June 2013

The English Short Title Catalogue

For the last several weeks I have been working on an article that explains the Scottish minister John Erskine's relationship with the English Particular Baptists, John Collett Ryland and his son John Ryland Jr. This has involved examining the letters that Erskine wrote to the Rylands in the last quarter of the eighteenth century.

In nearly every letter by Erskine, he included gratuitous works. My search has verified what the Presbyterian minister and church historian Samuel Miller said about Erskine in his Memoir of the Rev. Charles Nisbet (one of Erskine's correspondents):


But of all Dr. Nisbet’s correspondents in Great Britain, the most persevering and punctual was the venerable Dr. Erskine, of Edinburgh, one of the most pious and public spirited men of his day.  That gentleman probably maintained a more extensive correspondence with American clergymen than any other European Divine.  And probably, no private man on the other side of the Atlantic ever sent so many books gratuitously to this country as Dr. Erskine.  He probably had twenty or thirty correspondents in different parts of the United States; and it is believed that almost every letter he wrote was accompanied by a package of books.

In my book, Enlightened Evangelicalism: The Life and Thought of John Erskine, I talk about how Erskine forwarded religious publications to correspondents in America, Britain, and the Netherlands, including the Rylands. But I have now cataloged a list of the specific titles that the Rylands received from him. I calculate that Erskine posted about 400 texts to Ryland Jr. alone in the twenty-three years of their correspondence. This amounts to more than 4 texts per letter.

While researching the titles of the works that Erskine sent to the Rylands was a laborious process, involving many hours of searching, it would have been impossible without the use of the English Short Title Catalogue (ESTC) made available by the British Library. Using the ESTC database, I could search for pre-1801 publications using a number of parameters and was able , in most cases, to identify the precise edition that Erskine posted. The ESTC is just one more tool that academics have to aid them in their research in the current digital age--and I am grateful.

Sunday, 9 June 2013

The Global Diffusion of Evangelicalism

On my flights home from Boston I finished reading Brian Stanley's The Global Diffusion of Evangelicalism: The Age of Billy Graham and John Stott. This is the latest book in the "History of Evangelicalism" series with IVP Academic.

Stanley's book narrates the spread of evangelical Christianity in North America, Great Britain, and Australasia, highlighting the movement's key leaders and events. After an introductory chapter as an overview of the book, chapter two details the differences between fundamentalists and evangelicals around the mid-twentieth century with attention given to individuals such as Carl F. H. Henry, Harold J. Ockenga, Harold Lindsell, and Charles E. Fuller within the context of the rise of Billy Graham's ministry and the support he received from J. Howard Pew. Chapter one also chronicles the founding of Christianity Today and Fuller Theological Seminary as key events at this time.

While much of this information has been previously discussed in books such as Joel Carpenter's Revive Us Again: The Reawakening of Fundamentalism and George Marsden's Reforming Fundamentalism: Fuller Seminary and the New Evangelicalism, Stanley offers a fascinating comparison between American and British evangelicalism. We find out, for instance, that very few Christians in Britain wanted to form separatist groups, with most wanting to stay within the fold the established churches in England and Scotland.

In this second chapter, I found Stanley's analysis of the disproportional influence of the Plymouth Brethren on evangelicalism in Britain very interesting as well. Regent College doesn't advertise this fact, but it was founded by people like James Houston and Ward Gasque, a student of the Brethren biblical scholar F. F. Bruce, all of whom were Brethren (the current president of Regent College, Rod Wilson and the theologian John Stackhouse, were also raised Brethren).

The third chapter is about the global dissemination of evangelicalism that occurred after mid-century. There is an interesting section on the globalization of Billy Graham's ministry, which gives greater details regarding his involvement in various countries outside the U.S.

Chapter four gives an overview of some of the theological debates among evangelicals. This chapter has some really insightful material on the formation of Tyndale House in England, F. F. Bruce's scholarship, how British evangelicals have successfully infiltrated major research universities (as opposed to American evangelicals), the importance of The New Bible Commentary, disputes over the term inerrancy, and the revival of expository preaching led by D. Martyn Lloyd-Jones and John Stott.

Chapter five offers another theological perspective of evangelicalism, this time concentrating on the apologetic tone during the latter half of the twentieth century. Attention is given to Cornelius Van Til, Edward J. Carnell, Carl F. H. Henry, Francis Schaeffer, Alvin Plantinga, Lesslie Newbigin, and C. S. Lewis as key apologists of the movement.

Chapter six focuses on the issue of social justice within Christian mission and on the importnace of the 1974 Lausanne conference. Stanley explains the origins of the Lausanne Congress, the new evangelicals in Latin America, Africa and Asias, the initial skepticism of British evangelicalism towards Lausanne, the various debates among participants at the conference, and the significant role that John Stott played in drafting the Lausanne Covenant.

Chapter seven summarizes the history and tremendous impact that Pentecostalism has had had on global evangelicalism. Stanley begins by detailing the revival of divine healing that took place nationally, the sacramental nature of the charismatic movement, and key moments in history, such as the Toronto Blessing.

Chapter eight is about different hermeneutic expressions within evangelical Christian as well as issues tied to gender, sexuality, and ethics.  Stanley analyzes the place of women within evangelical churches and debates on how to interpret female involvement in worship services in light of various biblical texts. There is mention also of the differences between egalitarians and complementarians. The final sections of the chapter deal with the subject of homosexuality and differing Christian viewpoints.

The last chapter raises questions on where evangelicalism is going in terms of its trajectory. Stanley identifies trends from the middle to the end of the twentieth century, the significance of the charismatic movement going forward, and "post-evangelicalism" vs. "post-conservativism."

Overall, Stanley provides more evidence of the extremely diverse nature of evangelicalism. He shows that it is impossible to describe evangelicals as having unanimous opinions on biblical interpretation, missions, theology, interaction with culture, and the work of the Holy Spirit. One of the aspects of the book that I was most impressed with was Stanley's interaction with the current literature. Even though The Global Diffusion of Evangelicalism is hot off the press, Stanley made significant room to appraise recent books such as Andrew Atherstone's and David Ceri Jones's edited volume, Engaging with Martyn Lloyd-Jones (2011), Alister Chapman's Godly Ambition: John Stott and the Evangelical Movement (2012), and Tim Grass's F. F. Bruce: A Life (2011). Stanley's The Global Diffusion of Evangelicalism is an excellent contribution to IVP's "History of Evangelicalism" series, and should be read by anyone wanting a good summary of the last fifty years of the movement.

Friday, 7 June 2013

Fourth Day of Research--Boston

Today, I concluded my research in New England. I am now in Boston, where I spent all morning at the Massachusetts State Archives, which is on the UMass campus, across from the JFK Library.

The MA State Archives holds microfilm copies of most of the births, marriages, and estate records for state residents. The equipment is ancient though, and does not allow patrons to scan copies to pdf. Rather, your options are either to take digital images of the microfilm screen and/or print copies (which surprisingly are free). Interestingly, I found out that Samuel Kneeland, the colonial Boston printer and sometimes publisher, died broke (assets less creditors' claims). I wrote an article on Kneeland in the journal, Printing History (for my article summary, click here), but did not include his estate records or legal claims against his partner, Timothy Green. I hope to include more of this information in my upcoming presentation at the American Society of Church History annual meeting at Washington D.C. next January.

After finishing my research, I returned my rental car and checked into the Marriott Long Warf in Boston. This is a sweet hotel on the east side of historic Boston. One of the perks of working for a state university is that I can book hotel rooms as a government employee. In fact, I must do this to be reimbursed by UTC. As a government employee my hotel expense must be at the designated per diem rate. So in my case, I booked a room at the Marriott Long War for $201 even though the normal rate for my room was around $400.

I was hoping to do some sightseeing today before I fly home tomorrow, but as it raining, I may stay inside and start sorting through the material I have collected. Overall, this has been a fun and fruitful research trip.

Thursday, 6 June 2013

Third Day of Research--New Haven

I am now at my hotel in Foxborough, Massachusetts, after a two-hour drive from New Haven, Connecticut.

I spent all morning at the Sterling Memorial Library at Yale University in the manuscript room, where I looked at the Joseph Bellamy Papers. This is another amazing library at Yale, with engraved stone carvings within the building (see image to the right).


After working all morning, I had lunch with Ken Minkema and talked with him about my project, and asked him several questions that I had from my research so far. I hope that I can return to Yale again next summer to continue my research.

In order to get a head start at the Massachusetts State Archives tomorrow, I drove two hours northeast to Foxborough, Massachusetts, where I booked a room for the night. I hope to spend only the morning at the state archives so that I can return my rental car early, enjoy some sightseeing in Boston before my return flight on Saturday morning.

Wednesday, 5 June 2013

Skyline Time

My wife sent me a picture of what I am missing while away from my family. Here is my youngest son eating a "3- Way" at one of my favorite casual dining restaurants--Skyline Chili.

Second Day of Research--Harford and New Haven

Today, I did research at the Connecticut State Library, finished my work around noon, and then made my way to New Haven to look at the Jonathan Edwards Papers at Yale's Beinecke Library. I am absolutely exhausted.

The Connecticut State Library has basically all their records (marriages, births, churches, and estates) on microfilm. It cost me about twenty dollars in copying fees before I figured out that I could scan the images to a pdf file and save them to a flash drive for free. Lesson learned. That is the trick to researching at various archives. Once you figure out the system, it is much easier if and when you return. But the first visit can sometimes cost you lots of time and money.

I have been to Yale's Beinecke Library (a very cool building--see the images at the top right (inside) and bottom left (outside)) four times now, and almost have the system down. I noticed, however, that Yale has relaxed many of its policies regarding manuscripts, allowing patrons to take digital images freely and without even a marker that identifies the Beinecke Library (although you do check off on an electronic website that you agree to abide by the policies of the library and ethical behavior). Also, I noticed during this visit that patrons order all their materials online--that is a new system from the last time I was here when I filled out a paper slip for each order. All-in-all it has been a good day. I collected hundreds of digital images of manuscripts and hope that there is a lot of material in these that will aid future publication projects.

Tomorrow, I will head back to Yale where I will have lunch with Ken Minkema and then make my way to Foxborough, Massachusetts where I will spend the night. On Friday, I plan on getting up bright and early to make my way to the Massachusetts State Archives for one final day of research. After that I hope to relax, eat some Legal Seafood, and check into my hotel in downtown Boston.